Building your MyPLAYER lot of mlb 25 stubsshortstop in MLB The Show 25 comes with strategic choices. One of the most important decisions is selecting a team where your path to the majors is not only possible, but also efficient. Here, “best” means the fastest route to the big leagues, the right developmental environment, and support to thrive once you arrive.

First, consider rebuilding teams with low-rated shortstop options. The Milwaukee Brewers fit this model perfectly, as their top shortstop clocks in at a mere 64 overall. That leaves a huge performance gap for your player to fill. In this scenario, a strong spring or early season could fast-track your call-up, especially if you pour your early training tokens into boosting your own attributes. The roster’s weak depth at short means that once you outshine the placeholder, the move to the major leagues is inevitable and swift.

The Cleveland Guardians offer a similar path. Their shortstop sits in the high 60s, while other core positions are rock solid. A shortstop who can hold his own offensively or defensively could come up and immediately push for a spot, especially when paired with a lineup featuring strong performers. It's a unique opportunity: you join a respected club, contribute meaningfully, and benefit from their overall stability.

The Atlanta Braves provide a different advantage. Though their existing shortstop isn’t quite as low rated—around 70 overall—what makes them appealing is the depth of talent at almost every other position. Joining this team as a shortstop puts you among elite company. Despite facing a bit more competition, the upside includes growing alongside strong hitters and pitchers, enhancing your visibility and helping your player’s reputation flourish. Your performance stands out more meaningfully because the team itself demands excellence.

Another solid choice is the Arizona Diamondbacks. Their shortstop rating hovers in the mid to high 70s, offering a balanced opportunity: not too easy to dominate, but also not mired by established superstars standing in your way. You develop alongside strong team context and still have room to rise quickly. It’s one of the top ten teams overall, and investing in your player early gives you time to prove yourself without being overshadowed.

Finally, the Seattle Mariners offer a hybrid scenario. Their shortstop is in the low 70s, and the team around them features one of the best pitching cores in the league. That gives you extra developmental time in the minors, while still being surrounded by talent that can help carry the team. Once you break through, you’ve proven yourself in a competitive lineup and pitch for the big club when you’re truly ready.

In summary, the best teams for shortstops in MLB The Show 25 depend on your priorities: wanting rapid promotion, strong team support, or moderate pace with room to grow. Teams like the Brewers or Guardians offer speed, while the Braves, Diamondbacks, and Mariners offer environments that balance competitiveness with opportunity.